Morale rose among the . Answer (1 of 5): [The National Interest.] What if Hitler had won World War 2? Early Successes. The Germans had no forward base in the New World. The Allies could have won the Battle of France in May 1940 and France would have been the major contributing factor. In the bloodied fields of snow around Moscow, Adolf Hitler had suffered a breathtaking defeat. It had already had its minor revolution, the uprisings of 1905, leading to political reforms and the creation of a Russian parliament, the Duma. (Finland had been ruled by Russia until 1918, when anti-Bolsheviks prevailed in a Finnish civil war.) Play War Thunder for free using this link and get a free tank or aircraft and three days of premium time: http://v2.xyz/WarThunderOnAlternateHistoryHubOh loo. What if Germany had gone for Russia first in WWI? What would happen if the Germans won the battle of Stalingrad? Russia had its own problems. What if D-Day Had Failed? | Armchair General Magazine - We ... In many respects, Barbarossa was a stunning success. If Germany Won WW1, What About the Colonies? | History Forum Explanation: In Robert Harris' novel Fatherland (the basis for a 1994 TV movie), Nazi Germany successfully invades Russia in 1942. GERMANY (W.W. II, 1939-1945) Adolf Hitler planned to create a New Order--a united Europe ruled by Nazis for the benefit of Germany. The Germans took the Soviets completely by surprise, advanced hundreds of miles in just a few weeks, killed or captured several million Soviet troops, and seized an area containing 40 percent of the USSR's population, as well as most of its coal, iron ore, aluminum, and armaments industry. Read, more elaboration about it is given here. In fact, most military and civilian officials evacuated the city between 14-28 October 1941. In speculative literature, the Hypothetical Axis victory in World War II is a common subject in works of alternative history (fiction) and of counterfactual history (non-fiction) which examine public and private life in the lands conquered by the Axis powers — Germany, Japan, and Italy — in the Second World War (1937-1945).. Germany was beyond Poland, Czechoslovakia, Romania, etc, which were not the natural dominions of Germany, and Stalingrad was already one distant corner, in the military ambitions of Germany, in the Soviet Union. Had Germany not attacked Russia, there would never have been the Battle of Stalingrad. One suspects that if the Germans pursued a policy of aggressive colonial expansion in the 1920s and 30s, they might have succeeded in alienating the Japanese, who could have . Paul von Rennenkampf, Russian general, 1854-1918, commander of the 1st Russian Army during 1914. A much better question than, what if Hitler had won WW2. If France and Britain had not betrayed Poland in 1939, WW2 ... Without that conflict with Stalin's forces, Germany would have been free to focus its efforts on Britain and actually conquer it. Alternate History What if Germany Had Won World War II Ever since the Cold War, many Soviet and Russian politicians and academics have downplayed the role that U.S.-provided weapons and supplies played in the Red Army's ultimately victorious campaign . What if Germany stayed defensive on Western front in WW1 ... If Napoleon had secured his supply lines, maintained proper winter equipment, and established winter quarters, he still wouldn't have beaten Russia. Russo-Japanese War - Wikipedia Assuming that . Russia's 1914 Invasion of Germany - The Beginning of WWI ... Within a year, the man himself would be dead and his forces defeated. I'm assuming that Germany and the Soviet Union make peace after it becomes clear to Germany that the Soviets won't be defeated in 1942. With the Eastern Front out of the way and France and the UK already bloodied by their initial attacks upon German positions, the odds of Germany successfully getting France and the UK to seek terms prior to US involvement at all become far higher. A weak Russia exists but the Soviet Union collapsed when they surrendered to Nazi Germany. The USSR won over the forces of Nazi Germany, thereby completely seizing the initiative during the war. Russia made a decisive contribution to the war that turned the tide. The military and strategic benefit to Germany would probably be minimal. yes, it was a threat but never the less it was a tool of Germany and Russia bleeding each other to death policy, so, British elite use the results. There is no appeal against the verdict of history. Germany would want to move on to conquer . Before the Battle of Stalingrad, Britain . 2. Russia would then be defeated in two weeks at most and with minimal losses to German troops. As it turned out, Stalin ended up using the nationalism of Ukraine and other Soviet republics to defeat the Germans instead of the other way around which represented a major missed opportunity for Germany that helped ensure they lost the war. The last thing Stalin wanted was a war with Poland, France and Britain after Germany was defeated. For Germany to win the USA would not have entered the war. The results of the battle of Stalingrad. Remember that, totally unlike the situation in WW2, in 1945, Germany, in 1917, was military intact and undefeated in Germany. To achieve this the major part of German industrial output and R&D had to be focused on strangling the sea lanes. Would Russia still have become the Soviet Union? How could Germany have won WW2? Germany was close to beating Russia,(capturing Moscow, Leningrad, and moving on to Baku) in the first years of the war. EmperorTigerstar said: 1. If the war had ended in 1916, Russia will quite possibly avoid the Russian Revolution and the Russian Civil War. "Germany would have had time to build more U-boats" a side effect would have been how many of the Russian sub fleet they picked up intact. Mainly because German victory in WW1 was actually a strong possibility. Again, they fought off the Germans. The full weight of the Luftwaffe would have been devastating. They signed the treaty a few hours before the deadline on June 24, 1919. With minimal improvements, they could have succeeded in holding the line in 1940. What if Poland had yielded the Polish Corridor to Hitler in 1939, without war, and then either (1) Poland let Germany troops occupy all or part of Poland, without war, or (2) the UK had stayed out of any German-Polish war, meaning that Germany in 1939 could have taken Poland and wouldn't have had to face a war with the UK? The results of the battle of Stalingrad. The illusion of invincibility that had caused the world to shudder in the face of Nazi Germany had vanished forever - replaced now by a sliver of hope. No Nazi Germany but likely something equally . What if Hitler Had Defeated Russia? One thing that could be said if Germany won in the end. Some experts claim that Russia was on the road to victory in the Great War but then it was abruptly sabotaged by selfish and cowardly politicians who organized the two revolutions in 1917, and who . Again, they fought off the Germans. Germany would also have lost an enormous portion of its army (nearly 400,000 soldiers), so they wouldn't be able to stay in Russia for very long. Allied bombing was one of the key reasons to German loss in the east, but the massive allied bombings started around 1943 - 1944, leaving Germany with about a year before that started to benefit from Russian industrial sector. 21 Votes) If Germany had won the Battle of Stalingrad, the Russians would have stopped at nothing to take back the city. the Soviet Union could concentrate its forces against Germany, thanks to a 1941 neutrality pact with its long-time rival Japan. On the other hand, the logistics of a. Revolution breaks out in defeated France and/or England and you have Bolsheviks In control of modern developed industrial states. The above map, by Wilhelm Greve, was published in Berlin in 1916. In actual history, it was completed in June, July of 1945. In just the double battle of Vyazma and Bryansk in October 1941, the Russians had 633,000 . If before that the German army was invincible, now it was forced to retreat with huge losses of both manpower and equipment. Germany's advanced ME262 jet fighter that should have swept the skies was grounded because of fuel shortages. "Even if Germany had defeated France and Russia, it would have had a pretty massive challenge on its hands trying to run the new German-dominated Europe and would have remained significantly . The USSR lost during the battle more than 1 million 200 thousand people who . the only way Germany could have defeated the UK is if the russian question was resolved, diplomatically or militarily. The only way he beats Russia is if they play his game and send armies for him to carve up. Only when it became apparent that France and the UK had betrayed their Polish allies and left them to die, he invaded Poland on September 17th, much later than what he and Hitler planned. Conflict on the Russian front was one of the main things that kept Germany from conquering Britain in OTL. Without the constant bombing by the Allies, Germany's scientists develop the atom bomb about the same time as the Americans but while the Americans have no way to deliver a bomb all the way to Germany, the Germans continue to develop their rockets and in short order have the ability to hit the . The Germans were faced with an unenviable task in June 1940 if they wanted to take Britain out of the war. If Joseph Stalin had not assumed the helm of the U.S.S.R. after Vladimir Lenin's death in 1924, than the most likely candidate for this task would have been Leon Trotsky. It's obvious that Hitler gambled everything by invading Russia, that attacking Russia and then failing to defeat it could only mean that Germany would be defeated. Britain may have been invaded well before June, 1944. Had Germany's Wehrmacht and Luftwaffe not been largely destroyed in Russia, the Normandy D-Day invasion would likely have been pushed into the Channel. With strategic overhaul, France could have defeated Germany by offensive operations and prevented escalation in Europe. On August 17, Rennenkampf's forces defeated a German raid at Stallupönen. The USSR had contingency plans to evacuate Moscow. The port of Sevastopol, Crimea, gives Russia a staging area for "anti-access" weapons in the Black Sea . The USSR lost during the battle more than 1 million 200 thousand people who . The small island had not been invaded by a foreign power since the 12 th Century and had resisted all subsequent attempts. Napoleon had defeated it again and reduced it to what amounted to a client state of France. The stories, novels, and plays of the alternative history genre . Accept one of Stalin's offers for an armistice. But closer to World War II, Russian tanks and artillery won the Khalkin Gol border battle in 1939, while the Red Army's armored blitzkrieg smashed Japan's Manchurian . Stalin and his henchmen were arrested as traitors and a second Russian Revolution took place to purge the hard-line communists who had lost the war. The German lines had been overstretched if one considers logistics. Now, what happens from this point forward is a bit of a mystery. This would not only mean that a Romanov Tsar might have still been on the throne of Russia today, but it would mean that Russia would have avoided the nightmare of Soviet Communism. The full weight of the Luftwaffe would have been devastating. Let's take a look at the situation in 1941 before the US entered the war. If anything, it might have hastened Germany's defeat. How would the world be different? Subscribe to The Infographics Show : https://goo.gl/QZs9xz CHAT WITH ME: http:. It wasn't until after WW2 that a defeated Germany became a focal point in the Cold War between the Western Alliance and the Soviets. The British Armed Forces, in particular the eminently powerful Royal Navy, stood guard, a bastion against anyone . "Germany would have had time to build more U-boats" a side effect would have been how many of the Russian sub fleet they picked up intact. WHAT 10 DEFEATED NATIONS PLANNED TO DO HAD THEY WON THE WAR 7. Russia had been defeated in the Russo-Japanese War of 1904-5, and during its intervention in the Russian Civil War, Japanese troops had advanced all the way to Lake Baikal. Please note: Russia and Japan had a history of recent conflicts. On the other hand, the logistics of a Middle Eastern offensive would have been daunting, due to the great distances and lack of Italian shipping capacity to transport fuel. Germany would take over other colonies in Africa that belonged to the British and French as their armies were already defeated, offering little to no resistance against this move. German aircraft mauled the Royal Navy in 1941-42, even while supporting the campaign in Russia. If France is defeated in 1914, Russia probably makes peace with Germany and Austria-Hungary fairly quickly. If Germany won WW1 based on American lack of intervention (France surrenders due to more mutinies and lack of advances, UK makes peace due to practical impossibility to win by this point, Germany lasts long enough to gain Ukrainian grain to where the blockade isn't as effective). On the 20 th, a far larger attack hit them at Gumbinnen. Answer #1. Neither of the two main German powers was strong enough to oppose the French from this time until 1813 and only with heavy Russian support along with a large drop off on the part of the French (Russia, early set backs in Germany). The first objective of this planned Soviet invasion of Europe was to. During the 'Phony war', the allies had ample time to . Russia had its own problems. As Allied terms for Germany's eastern borders became more apparent, some circles in Germany seriously considered going back to war, at least in the east. Germany could only defeat brittan through a sucsessfull commerce campaign. Germany was beyond Poland, Czechoslovakia, Romania, etc, which were not the natural dominions of Germany, and Stalingrad was already one distant corner, in the military ambitions of Germany, in the Soviet Union. There could have been a real hot race to make the bomb between US and Germany, if Germany conquered Russia. About what the defeated Germans would have done if they had won World War II. What happened was that British-led offensives in the summer of 1918 caused German leadership to panic and perceive defeat. If successful, Germany would move troops from the French front to the Russian front within a week's time using modernized railways (trains). Hitler now has time and resources to defeat Russia. Morale rose among the . The Germans were furious, but by that time they didn't feel that they had much choice but to sign. No atomic bomb. Russian submarines would slow down seaborne reinforcements to the Baltics, Holmes said. What you're missing is a Russia first policy could potentially allow Germany to knock Russia out of the war relatively quickly. Learning that Britain has broken the Enigma code, however, the . Germany would still have to maintain a fairly big presence on their border with the Soviet Union for obvious reasons, and I would see a split up of the Balkans between the 2 nations. GERMANY (W.W. Would Russia still have become the Soviet Union? Russia, Austria-Hungary and the Ottoman Empire continue to be unstable and fall apart at some point anyway. Agreed. Had Germany defeated the USSR, Hitler would have acquired a plethora of resources - including the oil fields, which would have enabled Germany to become a superpower. 4.8/5 (113 Views . If Russia fell by Germany, it probably would have hastened Manhattan Project. Germany becomes the big swinging dick in Europe for a while. German aircraft mauled the Royal Navy in 1941-42, even while supporting the campaign in Russia. In any scenario in which the German army takes Stalingrad, the bloody street-to-street combat ensures the Germans will suffer great losses, impacting the effectiveness at which it can continue to carry out its eastern offensive. The German Army would never be the same. The USSR won over the forces of Nazi Germany, thereby completely seizing the initiative during the war. Germany lost air superiority in the East during Stanlingrad and never regained it. Paul von Rennenkampf, Russian general, 1854-1918, commander of the 1st Russian Army during 1914. If they had seized Iceland, any of the French protectorates in the Caribbean, or northern South America, then an invasion, while still a stretch . France never had the manpower to occupy enough of Russia to make a difference in the conflict. Wilhelm went on to assure Nicholas that once Russia had defeated Japan, this would be a deadly blow to British diplomacy, and that the two emperors, the self-proclaimed "Admiral of the Atlantic" and the "Admiral of the Pacific", would rule Eurasia together, making them able to challenge British sea power as the resources of Eurasia would make . In the West, the US and UK had defeated the Luftwaffe so badly, that on D-Day the Luftwaffe flew only 13 sorties against the Normandy beaches, and of those 13 aircraft, only 3 (or 4) actually made it to attack the beach - by strafing runs only. Answer (1 of 45): According to the Russian historian Sokolov, who answered this question in a recent radio broadcast dedicated to the "what-if" questions about WWII, if Hitler had miraculously defeated the USSR, for example if he had decided to drive on Moscow instead of Stalingrad in 1942, defea. The project was started in 42, or 43. The USA would have still boomed in the 1920s, depression in the 1930s, ect. Russia had been defeated. During the first three months, the Russians suffered military casualties of 200,000 in killed and wounded. This became painfully obvious to Hitler during the 1941-42 Battle of Moscow, when the Red Army's well-trained and well-equippe. It's important to realize that Germany was never totally defeated in WW1. What happened is irreversible and the historian, by definition, can do no more than study past events. (Germany actually declared war on the USA as a result of Pearl harbor.) The Russians had the largest sub fleet in the world IIRC - and then there is the bonus of picking up the eastern and western fleets (probably completely intact for the eastern fleet) In one fell swoop they would have narrowed Fishers "3 Powers" philosophy . When the German invasion of Russia began in June 1941, Germany could potentially defeat Russia and win the war. On the 20 th, a far larger attack hit them at Gumbinnen. By June 1941, the Red Army boasted seven times more tanks and four times more combat aircraft than invading German forces. Pretty much all of Europe had been invaded and China was under the thumb of Japan. There was no Eastern Front. It shows a "liberated" Flanders, France's northern provinces under occupation and Germany in control of the left bank of the Rhine. It's attacks had failed, but it's troops held the line in France and the Lowlands. The country would have imposed peace on the defeated allies at the treaty of Potsdam, and it would not have had the reparations and grievances that were generally inflicted by France and Versailles. Combined, a majority of Russians blamed the high casualties on Nazi Germany invading the Soviet Union in a surprise attack after it had signed a nonaggression pact (36 percent) or on Germany's. As a consequence, the rise of Hitler would have been less likely. A fascinating speculation on what might have happened for the future of the world if Operation Barbarossa against the Soviet Union had been successful. That's why Germany surrendered when it did. If before that the German army was invincible, now it was forced to retreat with huge losses of both manpower and equipment. Things began well for the Russians. WHAT 10 DEFEATED NATIONS PLANNED TO DO HAD THEY WON THE WAR 6. Its initial victories were tremendous. On Tuesday, 6 June 1944, D-day kicked off the Allied operation to liberate Western Europe from Nazi control. Once England was taken over, the rest . I no doubt believe that Hitlers Germany ,invading in 1941, could have defeated Stalin's Russia had Hitler not underestimated his enemies , and prepared Germany for a long war against the U.S.S.R. Last edited by SOVRAN on 12 Oct 2006, 17:37, edited 2 times in total. Had Germany won the war, Kaiser Wilhelm II would have annexed parts of Belgium, including its coastal regions, and made the remainder into a client state. Germany had six weeks to defeat France before Russia attacked her. But poor planning and harsh conditions abruptly ended Hitler's dream of northern Germany. As history tells us, Operation Overlord was a success as Allied forces managed to breach Hitler's impregnable 'Fortress Europe'. Aug 23, 2014. The German lines had been overstretched if one considers logistics. #9. Things began well for the Russians. Granted, Germany would have inflicted a severe treaty on the Allies; the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, signed by Russia and Germany after Russia's defeat, is indicative. On August 17, Rennenkampf's forces defeated a German raid at Stallupönen. In our "timeline" the Axis powers, primarily consisting of Nazi Germany, the Empire of Japan, and the Kingdom of Italy, were defeated by the cooperation between 3 major powers (and their smaller allies); The United Kingdom of Great Britain, along with her Dominions and Empire, the United States of America, and the Soviet Union. It had already had its minor revolution, the uprisings of 1905, leading to political reforms and the creation of a Russian parliament, the Duma. The Russians had the largest sub fleet in the world IIRC - and then there is the bonus of picking up the eastern and western fleets (probably completely intact for the eastern fleet) In one fell swoop they would have narrowed Fishers "3 Powers" philosophy . Germany had its own propagandists dreaming of a great victory in Central Europe. If the USSR fell, most of the world would fall like dominoes to the Germans and the Japanese. What exists today is a pseudo-democratic nation with questionable politics much like we see in the real world. Early Successes. I, 1914-1918) Germany's primary objective was to become Europe's major military and political power. Its obvious constituents would have been Britain, the United States and Russia, assuming Britain and Russia had a sufficient degree of independence to pursue such a policy. The Nazis enslave the 150 million inhabitants of European Russia, annihilate the 11 million European Jews, and ruthlessly pursue a eugenics program of selective breeding of "Nordic stock" and the mass sterilization of "inferiors." Germany's only remaining adversary is the United States. If France is defeated in 1914, Russia probably makes peace with Germany and Austria-Hungary fairly quickly. Had Germany won the Stalingrad battle then they would have been capable of severing all logistical supplies into the interior of Russia because they controlled the river Volga . During four months of harsh winter fighting against brave and defiant resistance, more than 200,000 Red Army soldiers died (Nikita Khrushchev said in his memoirs that the figure was closer to a million)—dwarfing the Finns' military fatalities. The UK would have suffered a rather bad defeat but it is unlikely that the German Empire would be able to inflict a huge defeat on the British Empire. It was the single biggest defeat in the history of the German army and the battle took a hefty toll on the Nazi cause.
Presenting Google Analytics Data, Econo Lodge Buffalo South, Roadkill Garage Model A, Genoa Vs Inter Predictions, False Claims Act Cases 2020, Villa Paradiso, Batroun Menu, Portable Blu-ray Player Walmart, Wisconsin Men's Soccer Coaches, Infosecurity Magazine, Jackie Curry John Boy And Billy, Boise State Men's Soccer Roster, ,Sitemap,Sitemap
